A History of Clewer

6. The Churchyard

The Clewer Group

"HERE LIES"

 

A SELECTION OF SOME OF THE

INTERESTING PEOPLE BURIED IN THE

CHURCH AND CHURCHYARD AT CLEWER,

WINDSOR, BERKSHIRE

 

Research by Vivien Hand, Catherine Lunn, Doris Morris and Denis Shaw

We gratefully acknowledge the kindness of the Proprietors, Editor and Staff of the Windsor and Eton Express in allowing our researchers to consult their records.

Contents

A VISITATION OF GOD - QUARTERMASTER EDWARD ADAMS *

AN ENGLISH BARONET WHO WAS A PORTUGUESE BARON - SIR FRANCIS TRESS BARRY *

KEEPER OF THE PRIVY PURSE - SIR THOMAS MYDDLETON BIDDULPH *

FATAL ACCIDENT AT CLEWER MILL - JOHN BRACKENBURY *

A DIRECTOR OF THE GREAT WESTERN RAILWAY - CAPTAIN THOMAS BULKELEY *

THE RECTOR THEY WANTED TO PROSECUTE - THOMAS THELLUSSON CARTER (1808 - 1901) *

A PROFITABLE GAFFE AT WINDSOR RAILWAY STATION - MISS MARY ANN GLOVER *

A GREAT PIONEER - SIR DANIEL GOOCH *

A MILITARY AUTHOR - COLONEL JAMES JOHN GRAHAM *

A DESCENDANT OF MARTIN LUTHER - MISS MARY ANN ELIZABETH KELLNER *

A RESPECTED PUBLICAN - WILLIAM JOHN McCLOSKIE *

THE MAGDALENS *

"DREADFUL SUICIDE" OF A CHURCHWARDEN - CHARLES NEWMAN *

"SHOCKING ACCIDENT BYDROWNING" - MR HENRY PAYNE, Draper's Foreman. *

A JUDGE WHO WAS AN AGRICULTURIST - SIR HENRY PROCTER *

QUEEN VICTORIA'S "DEAREST LILY" *

BUT WHEN DID BARBARA DIE? THOMAS AND BARBARA DUCK *

A FAITHFUL OLD SERVANT. MRS ANN WOODS *

THE LADY OF THE MANOR. LADY MARY BROCAS *

A VETERAN OF WATERLOO. HENRY ROBINSON MONTAGU *

"A DISPISER OF YE WORLD." MRS LUCIE HOBSON *

A RESPECTED PUBLICAN. THOMAS BEENHAM *

"THE ONE THAT GOT AWAY". ROBERT RICHARDSON-GARDNER *

A SPANISH WIDOW. MARIQUITA TENNANT *

A GENTLEMAN OF SUBSTANCE. JAMES DURDANT *

DROWNED ABOARD THE "TITANIC", 15th APRIL 1912 *

A FRIEND OF THE POOR. MRS HENRIETTA CECIL HENDERSON *

A ROYAL MESSENGER AND A ROYAL NANNY *

A POPULAR LOCK-KEEPER. CHARLES TULL *

EPITAPHS IN VERSE *

WAR GRAVES IN THE CHURCHYARD *

 

 

A VISITATION OF GOD - QUARTERMASTER EDWARD ADAMS

He died on October 17th 1819. His passing was, said the local paper, "a very awful instance of instant death".

 

As the Regiment of Royal Horse Guards was marching into the quadrangle of the infantry barracks, for the purpose of attending Divine Service, Quartermaster Adams fell down and "instantly expired, without uttering a word". The Coroner returned the following verdict: "Died by the Visitation of God"

 

Quartermaster Adams was in his 64th year. He had been 42 years in the Regiment and was its oldest member. "In the intercourse of private life he was universally beloved, and no man's memory will be attended with kinder recollections or deeper regrets, both in the Regiment, and in Windsor where had had been so long stationed." When the funeral took place at Clewer the procession included 50 Troopers of the King's Troop, with carbines reversed, the Band of the Regiment playing a solemn dirge. Six Quartermasters bearing the pall and Quartermaster Adams's horse, led by a Trooper.

 

We learn from the records of the Household Cavalry Museum that Adams had enlisted at the age of 21, that he was 5ft 11in, had light hair, grey eyes and a fair complexion. He was from the parish of Handley in Cheshire and had formerly been a draper. He became a Trooper in February 1795.

 

The Quartermaster's tomb, which is very close to the church door, on the left facing the Bridle Gate, has a very finely carved stone panel on its end, which is unfortunately wearing away. The carving depicts various emblems of war, including a riderless horse with its owner's boots reversed.

 

The newspaper report of the funeral makes it appear that the Quartermaster's two sons were named Mr Smith and Mr Siddall, in which case they must have had different mothers, neither of whom was married to Adams. However, no comment is made on this and it is difficult to be certain that this meaning is intended.

AN ENGLISH BARONET WHO WAS A PORTUGUESE BARON - SIR FRANCIS TRESS BARRY

He died in March 1907 at his home, St Leonard's Hill, Windsor, in his 83rd year. He was Conservative MP for Windsor from 1890 until 1906, when he resigned. He was mourned as "one of Windsor's greatest benefactors" (the Mayor, Alderman J Brown) and "a most generous and true-hearted friend to Windsor" (the Windsor & Eton Express). At the age of 16 Barry entered a commercial house at Bilbao in Spain. At 21 he was appointed Vice Consul for the Province of Biscay. He later joined his brother-in-law, James Mason, in the exploitation of the San Domingo copper mines in Portugal, and it was here that he made his fortune. In 1876 the King of Portugal created him Baron de Barry of Portugal. He bought St Leonard's Hill, Windsor in 1872 and became Consul General of the Republic of Ecuador in UK. He had a town house in South Audley Street, and a residence at Keiss Castle in Caithness. It was said that he bought his Scottish estate because, in Windsor, "the close proximity of Her Majesty's preserves renders shooting, to a man of honour, somewhat embarrassing." He several times lent St Leonard's Hill to the Prince of Wales for Ascot Week and spent between £3,000 and £4,000 in preparing the house. He bought, and presented to the town, the land which is now Alexandra Gardens. He worshipped at Clewer, when in Windsor, and his hatchment now hangs in the church.

 

His grave is on the first pathway to the right on entering the churchyard by the lychgate.

KEEPER OF THE PRIVY PURSE - SIR THOMAS MYDDLETON BIDDULPH

Thomas Biddulph was the son of Robert and Charlotte Biddulph of Chirk Castle. He was born in 1809 and entered the Army as a Cornet (1st Life Guards) in 1826. On his promotion to Lieutenant-Colonel in 1857 he went on half pay. He was later appointed Master of the Queen's Household, and then Receiver-General of the Duchy of Cornwall. In 1867 he was appointed Keeper of the Queen's Privy Purse. In 1857 he married the Hon Mary Frederica Seymour. Sir Thomas died at Abergeldie "after a short and sharp illness arising from inflammation of the lungs and bronchitis." He was attended in his illness by Sir William Jenner, the Queen's Physician. As soon as news was received at Windsor Castle of his death it was forwarded to the Queen at Balmoral. A messenger was also sent to the Prince of Wales who was out deer-stalking. He at once returned to Abergeldie and remained some time with Lady Biddulph. A Court Circular was issued, saying that the death had caused the Queen the "profoundest grief" and going on to say that the Queen had called on Sir Thomas daily, and, indeed, "had only just left the house when the sad event took place." Sir Thomas had enjoyed the Queen's trust and confidence for 27 years, but there had been one occasion when he had threatened to resign, because of rows with John Brown, the Queen's personal gillie and favourite. It is on record that the Queen made gentle fun of Sir Thomas behind his back: with roars of laughter she told Sir Henry Ponsonby how shocked Sir Thomas had been by the design for a medal of the Ashanti campaign and she quoted his comment, "Roman soldiers with nothing - nothing at all - but helmets on."

 

However, Sir Thomas was not without a sense of humour: in 1871, when the Queen was gravely ill with an abscess on her arm, Lady Churchill wanted to send for all her children. "Goodness", said Sir Thomas, "that would have killed her at once!"

 

Also buried at Clewer is Sir Thomas's son, Victor Myddleton Biddulph, who for many years had a close association with St Agnes' Church. "His artistic sense of the beautiful led him to bestow many valuable gifts both on the Parish Church and St Agnes' Church". He died in March 1919, and the funeral service was conducted by Dick Sheppard, who was then a Canon of St George's Chapel, Windsor.

FATAL ACCIDENT AT CLEWER MILL - JOHN BRACKENBURY

Aged 36, he was buried in Clewer Churchyard in September 1815, having been killed in an accident at Clewer Mill on August 29th. An inquest was held at the Swan Hotel, Clewer, on September 6th, the Coroner being Rupert Clark Esqr.

 

The Coroner and Jury viewed the body (at The Swan) "which presented a most ghastly appearance", then they went to the Mill to inspect the scene of the accident. They then returned to The Swan Jury Room. Thomas Aldridge, son of the proprietor of the Mill, told the Jury that Brackenbury had been grinding a mill-bill, his back being towards the lay-down shaft, when the rope attached to the grindstone got loose. Aldridge then said to the deceased, "Put the handle on", which he did and the wheel was then worked for about half an hour. Then, however, the rope tangled in the wheel and broke. As a result, the grindstone fell on Brackenbury's body. The stone was lifted, and Brackenbury, still alive, was "removed home in a vehicle". Edward Andrews, a surgeon of Sheet Street, gave evidence, having seen Brackenbury after the accident. There was bruising, three ribs had been broken, and breathing was difficult. Brackenbury died the following day and it was the surgeon's opinion that the cause of death was the sudden shock by which several vessels were ruptured. After half an hour's deliberation, the Jury decided that the deceased had been accidentally killed. The Coroner said that great care should be used in the selection of rope in the future and that the whole framework should be securely fastened to the floor.

 

Brackenbury's grave is situated on the left of the main path, facing the church, before the Churchyard Cross is reached, not very far in from the path. It is inscribed "Boast not thyself of tomorrow, for thou knowest not what a day may bring forth." {Proverbs 27.1}

A DIRECTOR OF THE GREAT WESTERN RAILWAY - CAPTAIN THOMAS BULKELEY

Aged 75, he was buried at Clewer in May 1882. He lived at Clewer Lodge, Windsor, and at Park Street, Grosvenor Square, London, and his death occurred at his town house. He was educated at Harrow and University College, Oxford. In 1828 he joined the 1st Life Guards as a Cornet. By 1837 he was a Captain and he retired in 1849. He was Chairman of the Windsor Branch Railway from Slough, and when the line was incorporated into the Great Western Railway he became a Director of that company. He was Chairman of the Great Western Hotel Company and was "the original promoter of the hotel, which was the first of that magnitude in London." He was an honorary member of the Jockey Club and was for many years the Acting Trustee of the Ascot Grand Stand. He was JP for Berkshire since 1839. He was President of the Windsor and Eton Literary and Scientific Institution. For the funeral, a special train brought his body from Paddington to Windsor. The Directors and officials of the Great Western Railway came by another special train, having adjourned a Board Meeting to be present.

 

This grave is some distance in, to the right of the path to the Bridle Gate, facing Clewer Court Road.

 

THE RECTOR THEY WANTED TO PROSECUTE - THOMAS THELLUSSON CARTER (1808 - 1901)

He became Rector of Clewer in 1844, by which time he had come very much under the influence of the Tractarian ("High Church") movement which had started at Oxford some ten years earlier. He found Clewer Church in a very dilapidated state, and at first thought of abandoning it and building a new church more in the centre of the parish. However, he then decided that the historic old church must be restored.

 

In 1849 he founded a House of Mercy for the rescue of "fallen women" - carrying on the work which had been started in the parish by Mariquita Tennant - and in 1852 he founded a Sisterhood (Community of St John the Baptist) to take care of it. Extensions of the work of the Community spread far and wide: hospitals, schools, missions, and homes of "rescue" were established in many parts of England, in India, in the West Indies and in the USA. In Clewer, there were: St Andrew's Hospital (a Convalescent Home) (1861); St John's Home "for girls of respectable parentage" (1885); St Stephen's College for the daughters of gentlemen (1867); St Stephen's High School for Girls (1881); St Augustine's Home for Boys, and St Andrew's Almshouses. His good works and his unquestioned personal holiness did not stop his parishioners from objecting to his "High Church practices." They petitioned the Bishop, repeatedly. All over the country disputes about such practices were taking place and there were often rowdy scenes. In 1874 the Public Worship Regulation Act was passed (with the hearty approval of Queen Victoria) to suppress the growth of ritualism in the C of E. However, through the endeavours of Archbishop Tait, built into the Act was a provision, which allowed a Diocesan Bishop to veto any proceedings being taken under the Act. A parishioner in Clewer, Dr Julius, brought pressure through the Courts to force the Bishop of Oxford to act against Carter. The Bishop was not sympathetic to Carter's "High Church" practices but he refused to subject a good man to vexations at the wishes of the Courts. He took the case to the Court of Appeal, which ruled in his favour against Dr Julius. The doctor appealed to the House of Lords, but they gave decision in favour of the Bishop.

 

It was then that Carter decided to resign, and from the highest motives; he had received the protection of the Bishop, but he could not, in good conscience, abandon practices of which, as he knew, the Bishop disapproved. "The only course compatible with honour was to resign". He explained all this in a letter to The Times and his conduct was universally applauded. So he ceased to be Rector in 1880 and concentrated on the affairs of the Convent, as Warden.

 

As he lay dying, he asked his daughter to leave the curtains open so that he could gaze upon the Evening Star and this is commemorated in the miniature bronze memorial to Carter in the sanctuary of Clewer Church.

 

His grave, where his wife and daughters are also buried, is near to the boatyard wall on the north-west side of the church. It can be reached by taking the path to the north, from the Churchyard Cross. One of Carter's favourite religious emblems, the passion flower, is carved upon it, and the same emblem can be seen on one of Carter's stoles preserved in the Clewer History Museum.

 

A PROFITABLE GAFFE AT WINDSOR RAILWAY STATION - MISS MARY ANN GLOVER

She died on March 5th 1910. She was the daughter of William Glover, who was Chief Tapissier to Queen Victoria (died in 1864, buried in Clewer Churchyard, with a gravestone paid for by the Queen: recently vandalised). When Miss Glover was a young girl, in the early 1850s, she went to Windsor Railway Station to watch the Queen's arrival by train. However, her father, William Glover, was in the entourage, and when Mary Ann saw him "she became oblivious of the presence of Royalty and ran to greet him."

 

The Queen noticed the incident and subsequently enquired who "the young person" was. She then commanded Mary Ann's presence at the Castle and enrolled her in the Royal service. Ultimately, Miss Glover "became in attendance upon the Princess Royal" and when the Princess married the Crown Prince of Prussia, Mary Ann accompanied the Royal bride to Berlin. This was in 1858 and Mary Ann remained in Prussia for a year. It was said, however, that the climate did not suit her and she was compelled to return to England. "Miss Glover was held in high esteem by the German Empress - as the Princess eventually became - who sent for her when on a visit to Windsor, not long before her (the Empress's) death and presented her with a private photograph of herself. Miss Glover possessed many souvenirs of the respect and esteem of the Royal Family." When Mary Ann returned to England the Queen presented her with an annuity for life, from the Privy Purse, and suggested that she should set up a school for young ladies. She took the Queen's advice and established Cambridge House, Grove Road. She continued to run the school until her death at the age of 74.

 

Miss Glover's grave is very close to the church, on the south west side. A separate stone commemorates her burial. Her father's stone which, as stated above, has been vandalised, had recorded on the back of it the occasions on which Queen Victoria visited the grave to strew flowers on it. There is a group of exhibits about the Glover family in the Clewer History Museum. The Kemp window, in the south side of Clewer Church, is in memory of Miss Glover's parents.

 

A GREAT PIONEER - SIR DANIEL GOOCH

He was born in Bedlington in 1816 and served an apprenticeship in the Stephensons' workshop. When he was barely 21 he was chosen by Isambard Kingdom Brunel to be the first locomotive superintendent of the Great Western Railway. He was the "creator" of industrial Swindon, for in 1840 it was he who chose the town as the site for the GWR workshops. The engines he designed and built there have the GWR pre-eminence in speed and reliability.

 

In the year 1860 he was appointed engineer of the Great Eastern steamship in succession to Brunel, who had died the previous year. He later converted her for cable-laying, helped to form the Telegraph Construction and Maintenance Company and, after one unsuccessful attempt in 1865, he successfully laid an Atlantic cable, returning home to find himself the first engineer baronet. He was again on board in 1869 when the Great Eastern laid a French cable from Brest to St Pierre. In 1865 he was elected MP for Cricklade and in the same year he became Chairman of the Great Western Railway - a post he held until his death in 1889.

 

In 1859 he bought the large house and grounds which stood to the west of Mill Lane, Clewer, and was known as Clewer Park. It had been the home of the Hon Henry Ashley, brother of Lord Shaftesbury, and Gooch bought it from Ashley's widow, later buying the freehold from a Dr Proctor. In later years, he loved above all else the peace of his Thames-side home at "pretty Clewer".

 

In the 1860s he replaced the irregular line of cottages on the west side of Mill Lane with the houses which stand there to this day, and he also rebuilt the frontage of The Swan. His coat of arms can be seen on one of the twin cottages near The Swan.

 

He chose the site for his grave in Clewer Churchyard in company with the Rector, T T Carter. When his wife, Margaret, died in May 1868, he wrote in his journal: "There must have bee some presentiment in my mind of this blow that has come upon me, for it is only a few months since I asked Mr Carter if I could have reserved a piece of ground in the churchyard where I fancied I should like to make my last resting place..." He grieved deeply for his wife, but he had a strange experience which led him to remarry, to a woman whom he scarcely knew, as he believed it was his first wife's wish. In March 1869 he wrote: "I had a strange dream …going to bed feeling very weary of life and almost longing for its end, I prayed to the spirit of my poor wife for comfort. ….I could not have been long asleep when, if it was dream or reality I know not, but she stood so plainly at my side, looking Oh so sad, yet she mentioned to me the name of a lady who is almost a stranger to me, one whom I have certainly not met more than half a dozen times, but who I have often heard my wife speak of in kind terms…" The following year he married the lady.

 

Gooch's vault is in the south east corner of the Churchyard, easily accessible by a path. It bears his arms in bronze. At his funeral the choir sang "Art thou weary…" in the Church and "Jesus lives…" at the graveside.

 

His second wife, who survived him until 1901, is buried in a separate grave nearby.

A MILITARY AUTHOR - COLONEL JAMES JOHN GRAHAM

He was buried in Clewer Churchyard in July 1883. At his death he was one of the Military Knights of Windsor. He was the son of General Graham, Deputy Governor of Stirling Castle.

 

Col Graham entered the Army as an ensign in the 70th Foot, in October 1824, having been a Cadet at Sandhurst. During foreign service he was employed on the staff of General Maister as Deputy Judge Advocate General. Returning home as a Captain, he went on half pay from the Army to take up a post in the "Secretarial" (sic) of the South Eastern Railway. Returning to military life, he went to Canada in command of a body of enrolled pensioners. He then held the post of "Staff Officer of Pensioners" in London and elsewhere.

 

On the outbreak of the Crimean War he was appointed Military Secretary, in the rank of Lieutenant Colonel, to General Vivian. For his services he received the Turkish Order and Medal.

 

In 1858 he wrote "The Elementary History of the Art of War". In 1862 he published, for private circulation, the memoirs of his father. He later published "Military Ends and Moral Means" which, it was said, "exemplified the higher instincts influencing military life." He also published a pamphlet entitled "The Constitution and Organization of Land Forces Reformed." His last literary activity was the editing of an English translation of the German work on "War" by von Clausewitz.

 

In addition to being a writer, Col Graham was an accomplished artist in water colour and crayons, and he painted both landscapes and figures.

A DESCENDANT OF MARTIN LUTHER - MISS MARY ANN ELIZABETH KELLNER

She lived at 12 Keppel Terrace, and died on August 11th 1884 in her 43rd year. Her grave is chiefly interesting for the inscription below her name (which is fast disappearing) which says "The Last Lineal Descendant of the English Branch of Martin Luther's Family". A number of other Kellners are buried in the churchyard and one of them was a Churchwarden in the early part of the 19th century. His name may be seen on one of the "Charity Boards" in the belltower. In the Parish Registers the occupation of all the Kellners is given as "Musician". George Kellner is described in the Registers (at the baptism of his son, George Desborough Kellner) as "Musician to His Majesty" and he is elsewhere described as "Oboe player in Queen Charlotte's Private Band". The Kellner who achieved most fame in his lifetime was Ernest Augustus (1792 - 1839). At the age of 5 he played a Handel concerto "before the King and his family". At 13 he became a midshipman on HMS PLOVER, but when his second ship, HMS ACASTA, was ordered to the West Indies, his parents got him out of the Navy. He studied music in Bath and sang in the theatre there. He then toured with the famous tenor, Charles Incledon. In 1813-1814 he gave concerts in London and toured Europe. When he died ("of a decline") he had over 100 compositions to his credit.

 

Mary Ann Elizabeth's grave is on the right of the path leading to the Bridle Gate.

 

A RESPECTED PUBLICAN - WILLIAM JOHN McCLOSKIE

Landlord of the Star and Garter, he died in May 1895 at the age of 58. A huge crowd attended his funeral, at Clewer, on May 18th. McCloskie was a Councillor, a member of the Windsor Fire Brigade, and a prominent member of the Licensed Victuallers' Protection Association. The members of the last named organisation paid for his gravestone. The funeral procession was headed by the Windsor Fire Brigade under Captain Dyson, followed by a detachment of the Eton Fire Brigade under Captain Dugdale. On the route from the Star and Garter to the Churchyard "the blinds of almost every house were drawn and nearly every shop exhibited mourning shutters". Members of Windsor Corporation, including the Mayor, Mr H Webber, met the cortege at the Lychgate, Representatives of Messrs Nevile Reid and Co (brewers) were present, as also were representatives of Windsor & Eton Football Club, Windsor Police, and the Royal Horse Guards. The service was read by the Reverend J Ellison (Vicar of Windsor), "this being his first and melancholy duty as Chaplain to the Corporation".

 

Oswald McCloskie, John William's son, was killed in 1896 at age of 23. After his father's death, he had gone out to Johannesburg "to work in the mines". He then "joined the movement promoted by the Reform Leaders" and volunteered his services to go to the Front to fight against the Matabele. He was killed while fighting with Colonel Plummer's relief column.

 

The McCloskie grave is near to the Churchyard wall on the Clewer Court Road side, to the west of the centre path.

THE MAGDALENS

The graves of many ladies who shared the surname MAGDALEN are scattered all over Clewer Churchyard. Some may be seen on either side of the path near the Bridle Gate. Visitors are puzzled by the fact that the "family" appeared to have no male members. The Magdalens, in fact, were the women who benefited from the rescue work of Canon T T Carter and the House of Mercy. If, after they had been "rescued" - some of them through the agency of Gladstone, in London - they showed signs of wishing to settle to a changed life, they remained on at the Convent and took the name "Magdalen" in reference to the penitent woman in the Gospels.

 

One Magdalen gravestone, which was broken, has been repaired and installed in the Clewer History Museum.

"DREADFUL SUICIDE" OF A CHURCHWARDEN - CHARLES NEWMAN

Charles Newman, who was Landlord of the Royal Adelaide Hotel, Windsor, and a Churchwarden of Holy Trinity Church, committed suicide on November 10th 1868. He cut his throat with a pruning knife which he had been using for peeling oranges. The occurrence "aroused much excitement" in the town. Newman, who was 39, had worked for the Brewery and Banking firm of Nevile Reid & Co for nearly twenty years before taking over the Adelaide. He was "a member of the Masonic Fraternity, and a strong supporter of the Conservative cause".

 

On the day of his death he was "just recovering from a deranged liver and nervous excitement" when a letter arrived with a dishonoured cheque that had been paid to him. "This occasioned a relapse and at 11 o'clock at night he destroyed himself in a dreadful manner".

 

An inquest was held at the Adelaide. Mr A H Marlin was the Coroner and Mr Alfred Williams was Foreman of the Jury. Mr John Cleave, Commission Agent, described how he had been in the Coffee Room of the Adelaide, with Mr Edginton Junr and Mr Chaney on the night of the tragedy. Mrs Newman entered in a distracted state and begged them to go upstairs to Mr Newman. They found him on the floor, which was covered in blood. Mr Newman muttered "They've threatened to send for the Police" and these were his last words. Dr Fairbank and Dr Bower had both attended him. Mr Henry Eschker of Denton Place said he had shared a bottle of claret with Newman on the day of his death. He had been very low-spirited. Then the letter with the dishonoured cheque arrived. Newman said "Here's a pretty thing - to lend a man money and have a cheque returned dishonoured." To rouse Newman's spirits Eschker suggested a game of cribbage, but after three games, Newman threw down his cards and said "I shall play no more". Dr Bower gave evidence that Newman had a deranged liver and stomach caused "by excessive free living". The wound in Newman's neck was sufficient to cause death. "I have no doubt"